Skip to main content

Results · Rosenberg Law Firm, PLLC

Appellate Results

Five appeals that show how we work: find the issue the record supports, and put it in front of the court that can fix it.

Five appellate results

  1. Murder and attempted murder convictions reversed; new trial ordered

    People v. Rodriguez · N.Y. Appellate Division, Fourth Department · criminal appeal after a jury trial

    Our client was convicted of murder and attempted murder in a case the prosecution built on circumstantial proof, and the trial court refused the defense request for a circumstantial-evidence instruction, the charge that tells jurors how to weigh a case resting on inference. On appeal we showed that his statements were not admissions of guilt, so the proof on those counts was circumstantial and the instruction was required. The Appellate Division agreed, reversed the murder and attempted murder convictions, and granted a new trial on those counts.

  2. Manslaughter conviction reversed

    People v. Major · N.Y. Appellate Division, Fourth Department · criminal appeal after trial

    Our client was convicted of manslaughter in the second degree after a trial in which justification was at issue. Once justification is raised, the prosecution must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt. Weighing the evidence on appeal, the Appellate Division concluded the manslaughter verdict could not stand on that record and reversed that conviction.

  3. Gun conviction reversed, evidence suppressed, indictment dismissed

    People v. Suttles · N.Y. Appellate Division, Fourth Department · appeal after a guilty plea

    Our client pleaded guilty to criminal possession of a weapon after the trial court refused to suppress a gun found when police stopped the car he was riding in. The officers stopped the car on visual guesses of its speed, without radar or pacing, and could not show the training to back those guesses. The Appellate Division held that the prosecution never proved the stop was lawful; it vacated the plea, suppressed the evidence and dismissed the indictment. A guilty plea did not end this case.

  4. Summary judgment for the government vacated; case sent back for trial

    Rubin v. United States · U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit · civil appeal (Federal Tort Claims Act)

    Our client was injured when a car owned by the United States and driven by a federal employee turned across his path. The district court granted summary judgment to the government and dismissed his negligence claims without a trial. The Second Circuit held that genuine disputes of material fact remained, including who had the right-of-way and whether the driver shared fault, vacated the judgment, and remanded the case for trial.

  5. New York's highest court orders the identification hearing the trial court denied

    People v. Carmona · New York Court of Appeals · criminal appeal

    The trial court refused our client a pretrial hearing on whether a witness's photo identification was merely “confirmatory,” accepting the prosecutor's bare assurance that the witness knew him. The Court of Appeals held that the assurance was not enough and that the Appellate Division was wrong to fill the gap with trial testimony. It sent the case back for that hearing and, if the identification cannot be justified, a Wade hearing and further proceedings, including a new trial, as the circumstances warrant.

These results were obtained by Rosenberg Law Firm, PLLC. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case turns on its own facts and law. Attorney Advertising.

Posted with client permission

“To open blind eyes, to bring prisoners out of a dungeon, those who sit in darkness out of a prison.”

Isaiah 42:7