Skip to main content

Federal appeals

Federal Appeals After a Guilty Plea

A waiver is not a wall. Some issues survive the plea, and some survive an appeal waiver.

If you pleaded guilty in federal court, you may still have an appeal. Clients are often told the opposite. The plea agreement looks final. The waiver looks absolute. Then the sentence comes in higher than anyone expected, or the plea itself does not sit right, and no one can give a straight answer about what is left.

See the firm’s recent appellate wins.

Here is the straight answer. In many federal cases you cannot relitigate guilt the way you would after a trial. But you may still be able to appeal the sentence. In some cases you may still be able to challenge the plea. And a waiver of appeal, even a signed one, is not always the end of the inquiry. The work is to read the agreement, the colloquy, the presentence report, and the judgment, and to find the issue that is still open.

A plea record is often shorter than a trial record. It is not simpler. The issues are fewer. The arguments have to be exact.

The limits of an appeal waiver

Federal plea agreements commonly include a waiver of the right to appeal. Courts enforce those waivers when they are knowing and voluntary. They also recognize limits. A waiver may not bar a claim that the plea itself was not knowing or voluntary. It may not bar a claim of ineffective assistance that goes to the plea. It may not bar a claim that the sentence exceeds the statutory maximum. The precise limit depends on the language of the agreement and the law of the circuit. We start there, with the document you signed and the words said in court, not with a slogan about "waiving everything."

The sentence is often the live issue

Even when the conviction itself is not open, the sentence may be. A wrong Guidelines range, a loss figure or an enhancement can change years of a person's life. See Appealing a Federal Sentence.

Sometimes the plea itself can be challenged

There are cases in which the conviction after a plea can still be reviewed: a plea that was not knowing or voluntary, a breakdown in the Rule 11 colloquy, a failure of counsel that goes to the decision to plead, or a plea without a factual basis. A guilty plea also does not, by itself, bar a claim that the statute of conviction is unconstitutional. Any of these is a reason to have an appellate lawyer read the transcript before anyone tells you nothing can be done.

Plea cases move fast after sentencing. If the judgment was entered recently, call (718) 715-4845 today. The sooner we see the judgment, the more options stay open.

Some claims belong in a § 2255 motion instead of, or after, the direct appeal. Ineffective assistance is often in that category. We will tell you which path fits the facts and pursue it.

If you asked your lawyer to appeal and no notice was filed

If you told your lawyer to file an appeal and no notice was filed, that may be a § 2255 claim, even with an appeal waiver. See Federal § 2255 Motions.

Questions

Can you appeal a federal case after a guilty plea?

Often you can appeal the sentence. In some cases you can also challenge the plea. It depends on the agreement, the colloquy, and the issues that were preserved.

I signed a waiver of appeal. Is that the end?

Not always. Waivers are enforced when they are valid, but they have limits. The only way to know is to read the waiver against the record.

How long do I have to file a notice of appeal?

From the criminal judgment, generally 14 days after it is entered, with limited exceptions. See Fed. R. App. P. 4(b). If that date is close, call us immediately. (An appeal from a later § 2255 ruling runs on a different clock; see the § 2255 page.)

What if the real problem is that my lawyer failed me?

Some of those claims are raised on direct appeal. Many are raised in a motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255. We will tell you which path is the honest one.

Is the initial consultation free?

Yes. The initial consultation is free.

Start today

You pleaded guilty. That may not be the last word.

If you or someone you love needs a federal appeal or post-conviction relief, call now.

Send a short note

A few quick questions. We call you back.

Is anyone in custody?

Calls answered 24/7. This inquiry is not legal advice and is not an agreement to represent you. Asking for a consultation does not extend any deadline.

Or call (718) 715-4845

“To open blind eyes, to bring prisoners out of a dungeon, those who sit in darkness out of a prison.”

Isaiah 42:7